A ‘win’ for abortion rights Monday doesn’t mean fight is over, say advocates

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of abortion rights Monday and struck down a Louisiana law in June Medical Services LLC v. Russo, but the “win” could be short-lived, say abortion rights advocates. The 5-4 decision brought an end to the legal battle over whether Louisiana’s 2014 law, that forced abortion providers in that […]

A ‘win’ for abortion rights Monday doesn’t mean fight is over, say advocates

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of abortion rights Monday and struck down a Louisiana law in June Medical Services LLC v. Russo, but the “win” could be short-lived, say abortion rights advocates.

The 5-4 decision brought an end to the legal battle over whether Louisiana’s 2014 law, that forced abortion providers in that state to obtain admitting privileges to a hospital within 30 miles of the clinic, is constitutional. The court, through Justice Stephen Breyer’s opinion, noted that the Louisiana law poses a “substantial obstacle,” to women seeking abortion, offered no significant health-related benefits nor showed evidence of how the law would improve the health and safety of women.

But, Chief Justice John Roberts, who sided with the more liberal wing of the court, wrote a concurrence in which he made clear he only voted in favor of June Medical Services because of precedent.

The court decided an almost identical case involving a Texas Law four years ago with Whole Women’s Health v. Hellerstedt. Roberts tends to vote with the conservative bloc of the court and said in his concurrence that he joined in the dissent against Whole Women’s Health. He said in his concurrence that he continues to believe Whole Women’s Health was wrongly decided.

“The question today is not whether it’s right or wrong, but whether to adhere to it in deciding the present case,” Roberts wrote.

Ellie Rushforth, reproductive rights attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union of New Mexico, said last week that the Supreme Court typically honors precedent.

Related: Reproductive rights under attack, say advocates. Here’s what you can expect.

Rushforth on Monday called the court’s decision “surprising,” but also said it doesn’t mean advocates for reproductive health care can rest easy because Roberts made evident in his concurrent that he is “no friend to abortion rights.”

“This is a moment to celebrate but also a moment to prepare for what comes next,” she said.

Nancy Northup, executive director of the Center for Reproductive Rights, which helped June Medical Services bring the suit against the state of Louisiana, said the nonprofit organization expects to be back in court soon and called the constant legal battles for abortion rights similar to “playing whack-a-mole.”

Rushforth said she thinks it is likely that one of the many six-week gestational bans that some states have rushed to pass in the last few years will be on the 2020-2021 docket. The Supreme Court starts deciding in early October which of the thousands of cases it is asked each year to hear, it will choose.

“There are a handful of (six-week gestational ban) cases making their way through federal circuit court right now,” Rushforth said. “We think it’s very likely that one will make it on the docket this (upcoming) term.”

A six-week gestational ban on abortion would not have precedent. 

When obstacles to abortion care are passed and then upheld by the courts, that produces a ripple effect and other states follow suit, activists have said.

Vicki Cowart, president and executive director of Planned Parenthood of the Rocky Mountains, while celebrating the “win,” said in her statement Monday that the Louisiana law was “a thinly veiled TRAP (targeted regulation of abortion providers) law that would have had disastrous impacts on health care access for patients, with ripple effects nationwide.”

Rushforth said that in 2006, in Gonzales v. Carhart, the Supreme Court upheld what conservative policy makers call a partial-birth abortion ban. Rushforth said the partial-birth abortion is a term that has no medical definition and serves to stigmatize women who seek abortion.

Since the court upheld that ban, states have passed around 500 abortion restricting laws, she said.

“There were plenty (abortion restricting laws) before 14 years ago, but the decision in the early aughts opened the flood gates,” Rushforth said. 

This particular bench is the first to hear an abortion case. President Donald Trump nominated both Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh and vowed to appoint only justices who would rule against abortion rights.

In their first test on the issue, both Gorsuch and Kavanaugh joined conservative Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas in dissenting. While the four justices wrote different opinions and had different perspectives on why the court should have ruled against June Medical Services, all four made it plain they found Louisiana’s arguments more compelling than Breyer did.

But abortion rights advocates, such as Joan Lamunyon Sanford, executive director for New Mexico Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice, said through a statement that Roe v. Wade “has never been enough to guarantee true abortion access.”

Groups like New Mexico Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice, Indigenous Women Rising and others support those seeking an abortion in New Mexico and help those who face barriers to still have access. 

When lawmakers put obstacles in the way of abortion access, communities of color are the ones who tend to suffer the most, said Charlene Bencomo, executive director of New Mexico nonprofit Bold Futures (formerly Young Women United).

Bencomo said the fact that access to abortion was upheld in Louisiana largely because of Roberts voting with the liberal block purely due to the Louisiana case having precedent makes her “nervous.”

“We know there are other cases in the cue that have not had precedent,” Bencomo said. “If they are tried, there could be a different outcome.”

One concern for abortion rights activists is that such laws, if allowed to stand, have a domino affect and other states begin passing such laws, further restricting access in more and more states.

Both Bencomo and Rushforth, as well as Lamunyon Sanford brought up the 1969 abortion ban still on New Mexico’s lawbooks. Bencomo said another effort at repeal would take place in the 2021 legislature.

A bill that would have repealed the 51-year-old law failed in the 2019 legislature. Almost all of the seven Democratic state Senators who voted against it lost their primary bid to more progressive challengers who support repealing the 1969 law. All Republicans in the chamber opposed the repeal.

Related: Primary wins for progressive Democrats a ‘mandate’ on abortion rights, say activists

Another question brought up by the case was whether abortion providers should be allowed to bring lawsuits on abortion-restricting regulations. Louisiana argued it was a conflict of interest.

Respect New Mexico Women, a coalition of reproductive healthcare advocates, said in a statement on Monday that abortion providers are “well situated to advocate on behalf of their patients’ interests.”

A coalition of Democratic Attorney Generals filed a brief with 22 Democratic Attorney Generals signing on, including New Mexico’s Attorney General Hector Balderas. The Democratic Attorneys General Association called the ruling a “victory for the rule of law,” through a statement. The court could rule on a case about contraception, Trump v. Pennsylvania, on Tuesday.

Correction: A coalition of Democratic Attorney Generals filed a brief in support of June Medical Services, not the Democratic Attorneys General Association.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

Legislators talk potential changes to criminal competency process

Legislators talk potential changes to criminal competency process

Criminal competency initiatives are a major part of public safety discussions by legislators and other state leaders both before and since the July 18…
LFC delivers BernCo crime update, offers suggestions

LFC delivers BernCo crime update, offers suggestions

A Legislative Finance Committee report said a way for New Mexico to try to alleviate its crime problems, it should seek to fix the…
‘Extreme disappointment’: Legislators discuss public safety challenges

‘Extreme disappointment’: Legislators discuss public safety challenges

The interim Legislative Courts, Corrections and Justice Committee discussed New Mexico’s crime situation during its meeting Monday.  Legislative Finance Committee staff presented on public…
Water managers warn the Rio Grande in Albuquerque will soon dry

Water managers warn the Rio Grande in Albuquerque will soon dry

The Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District warned that there will likely be minimal flows in the Rio Grande as it flows through the Albuquerque…
What is BIDEH and why do Republicans oppose it

What is BIDEH and why do Republicans oppose it

A Republican proposal pending before the U.S. Congress would require the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to rescind its pending rule related to management…
NM scientists receive DOE funding

NM scientists receive DOE funding

The U.S. Department of Energy announced this week that 91 early-career scientists in 26 states, including New Mexico, are receiving funding through the Early…
Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

About 200 people from tribal governors to legislators to advocates and teachers gathered at Bishop’s Lodge to discuss Early Childhood Education’s future in New…
Stansbury outlines funding secured for early childhood and youth services programs

Stansbury outlines funding secured for early childhood and youth services programs

U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury secured $8.3 million for childhood development and youth services in the 1st congressional district through federal community project funding. Stansbury,…
Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican The main things that bring Brayan Chavez to school every day: Seeing, talking to and engaging with…
As rhetoric around undocumented workers heats up, new report shows their tax contribution

As rhetoric around undocumented workers heats up, new report shows their tax contribution

A nonprofit group released data showing how much taxes migrants pay in the U.S. as rhetoric on immigration grows more prominent just months from…
Some mental health issues on the rise in New Mexico

Some mental health issues on the rise in New Mexico

A recent report by KFF, a foundation that provides health policy analysis, found mental health issues on the rise and disparities in mental health…
Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

U.S. Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Dr. Robert Califf answered questions about the safety of human milk formula and mifepristone on Wednesday. Sen. Martin…
New abortion clinic in Las Cruces expected to provide more abortion training

New abortion clinic in Las Cruces expected to provide more abortion training

One of the consequences of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision is the lack of abortion care training for medical residents training to become…
Las Cruces reproductive healthcare clinic expected to open as financial gaps in abortion care increase

Las Cruces reproductive healthcare clinic expected to open as financial gaps in abortion care increase

With 14 states now banning abortion and some abortion fund providers and abortion clinics in other states reporting donor fatigue, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham…
Guv: Las Cruces groundbreaking of new reproductive healthcare clinic ‘the beginning’

Guv: Las Cruces groundbreaking of new reproductive healthcare clinic ‘the beginning’

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham called the new full-spectrum reproductive health clinic in Las Cruces the beginning of a new reproductive healthcare infrastructure in the…
New abortion clinic in Las Cruces expected to provide more abortion training

New abortion clinic in Las Cruces expected to provide more abortion training

One of the consequences of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision is the lack of abortion care training for medical residents training to become…
Las Cruces reproductive healthcare clinic expected to open as financial gaps in abortion care increase

Las Cruces reproductive healthcare clinic expected to open as financial gaps in abortion care increase

With 14 states now banning abortion and some abortion fund providers and abortion clinics in other states reporting donor fatigue, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham…
Guv: Las Cruces groundbreaking of new reproductive healthcare clinic ‘the beginning’

Guv: Las Cruces groundbreaking of new reproductive healthcare clinic ‘the beginning’

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham called the new full-spectrum reproductive health clinic in Las Cruces the beginning of a new reproductive healthcare infrastructure in the…
New Mexico political parties react to presidential debate

New Mexico political parties react to presidential debate

Tuesday night marked the first and perhaps only debate between top presidential contenders former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris. Both the…
New Mexico SOS testifies on election preparedness, noncitizen voting

New Mexico SOS testifies on election preparedness, noncitizen voting

The Nov. 5 general election is less than two months away and with it comes the question of election preparedness and confidence. New Mexico…
RFK Jr. will remain on the ballot in New Mexico

RFK Jr. will remain on the ballot in New Mexico

Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. will remain on New Mexico’s general election ballot, despite dropping out of the presidential race. Candidates had until Aug. 27…
As New Mexico shakes, state cancels dozens of planned wastewater injection sites

As New Mexico shakes, state cancels dozens of planned wastewater injection sites

‘Guzzler.’ ‘Bottomless Pit.’ ‘Deep Thirst.’ ‘Big Swig.’  More like: ‘No Dice.’ The thirsty well names reflected the hopes of companies to fill them with oilfield…
Leger Fernández highlights NM’s mining legacy during permitting reform debate

Leger Fernández highlights NM’s mining legacy during permitting reform debate

Mining has been one of the key industries in New Mexico for more than a century, as U.S. Rep. Teresa Leger Fernández, a Democrat…
New abortion clinic in Las Cruces expected to provide more abortion training

New abortion clinic in Las Cruces expected to provide more abortion training

One of the consequences of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision is the lack of abortion care training for medical residents training to become…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report