• Donate Now
  • NM Political Report
    • logo
    • NM Political Report
    • About
      • About
      • Our Team
      • Donate
      • Send us a Tip

    NM Political Report - New Mexico's best political reporting. Period.

    NM Political Report (https://nmpoliticalreport.com/2018/07/18/same-sex-social-security-issue-heads-to-federal-court/)

    • News
    • COVID-19 coverage
    • Environmental Project
    • Elections
    • Donate
    • Republish our Stories
    July 18, 2018
    Anthony Gonzales

    Same-sex social security issue heads to federal court

    By AndyLyman | July 18, 2018

    Anthony Gonzales and Mark Johnson getting married at Albuquerque's Civic Plaza.

    Anthony Gonzales* met his future husband, Mark Johnson, at an Albuquerque gay bar, twenty years ago this month. Soon after, Gonzales and Johnson moved in and began their life together. In 2013, they made their union legally binding when they joined hundreds of other couples on Albuquerque’s Civic Plaza on the first day counties across New Mexico began legally recognizing same sex marriages. Almost six month later, 180 days to be exact, Johnson died of cancer.

    Now, just weeks before his wedding anniversary, Gonzales has filed a federal civil suit against the U.S. Government’s Social Security Administration for the monetary benefits he said he is owed. The suit, filed in June, asks for Social Security survivor benefits or money usually paid out to a surviving spouse. But, the Social Security Administration requires couples to be married for nine months before a surviving spouse can collect those specific benefits from their deceased partner. That’s the case for Gonzales and thousands of others, even though the administration grants other exceptions for those who have been able to legally marry for centuries.

    Gonzales said he is less concerned with the money and more motivated by moral principle.

    “Mark and I paid Social Security taxes our entire life,” Gonzales said. “It’s just a matter of fairness. We want to be treated like everyone else.”

    It’s in the details

    In 2015, Gonzales first applied for benefits, based on what Johnson paid into Social Security, and was promptly denied because the couple hadn’t been legally married for nine months. After exhausting all of the administrative options and even a push from U.S. Rep. Michelle Lujan Grisham to change the law, Gonzales is now asking a federal judge to weigh in.

    Wording, or lack thereof, within Social Security regulations is what seems to be preventing Gonzales from claiming money from Johnson’s Social Security.

    Part of Gonzales’ legal argument is that the Social Security Administration allows for other exceptions to collect financial benefits from a deceased spouse. If a spouse dies while in “in the line of duty” or deployed as “a member of the uniformed services” and was married for less than nine months, for example, the surviving spouse can collect survivors benefits. There is another exception  if one partner’s death was unexpected or accidental. Further, in a rather specific scenario involving behavioral health, the administrative code allows for a surviving partner to get benefits with no marriage at all. Under this exception if a couple is prevented from being married because one partner could not legally divorce a prior spouse due to “mental incompetence or similar incapacity” survivor benefits could be considered.

    While the Social Security Administration releases benefits to same sex couples who were unable to legally marry, the specific survivor benefits Gonzales applied for are not covered.

    As his lawsuit notes, a Social Security Administrative Law Judge who ultimately denied Gonzales’ administrative appeal encouraged Gonzales to take his case to court. The administrative judge said the “unequal treatment of same-sex couples who wished to marry prior to the legalization of same-sex marriage in New Mexico when compared to opposite-sex couples” and the fact that  non-married, same-sex couples qualified for certain other benefits warranted a federal court review.

    Still, Gonzales likely has a long road ahead of him.

    Just the beginning

    Gonzales told NM Political Report he’s struggled over the decision to move forward with his fight for survivor benefits since his first administrative denial.

    “It’s not easy,” Gonzales said of the process. “It brings back a lot of memories of Mark.”

    He has also heard polite encouragement to just drop the whole thing from some friends  and not-so-polite discouragement from commenters in the social media realm.

    “I try to ignore them,” Gonzales said of his more harsh critics online.

    But, he said, “If someone doesn’t fight for rights, nothing’s going to change.”

    The case is still in the early stages, no hearings have been scheduled and Gonzales is hesitant to speculate on an outcome, but is prepared for a long process.

    “It’s going to take years,” Gonzales said, considering the possibility of an appeal from either side.

    Whatever the outcome of his case, Gonzales said no court can offer him the ideal one.

    “I wish I wasn’t in this position, Gonzales said through tears. “I’d rather have him in my life than have to fight the government for something I deserve.”

    *Anthony Gonzales is the uncle of NM Political Report Editor Matthew Reichbach. Reichbach sat out of the editorial process of this story to avoid conflicts of interest. Instead, Environmental Reporter Laura Paskus edited Reporter Andy Lyman’s story.

    Author

    • AndyLyman
      AndyLyman

      View all posts

    Share this:

    • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
    • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
    • Click to print (Opens in new window)
    • More
    • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)

    Related

    • More About
    • News
    • Anthony Gonzales
    • federal court
    • Mark Johnson
    • Same sex marriage
    • Social Security Administration
    • Environmental advocacy groups decry SCOTUS Clean Water Act ruling

      Environmental advocacy groups say that a U.S. Supreme Court ruling weakening the Clean Water Act will put waters throughout the country at risk of pollution and degradation.  The ruling requires a more stringent test to determine if wetlands are protected under the decades-old law. The case, Sackett vs.

    • ECECD will soon see a nearly 68 percent increase in funding
    • As climate changes, researchers develop a new metric for evaluating water available from snowpack

    View all News articles →

    • Lujan Grisham bill would allow benefits for same sex couples who could not legally wed

      U.S. Rep. Michelle Lujan Grisham introduced a bill Friday that would amend the Social Security Act  to include some married, same sex couples that currently do not qualify for survivor’s benefits. Named for an Albuquerque resident, the Anthony Gonzales Equality for Survivors (AGES) Act, the bill would add alternatives for those who were not married for the minimum nine months in order to receive their deceased partner’s benefits.

    • ABQ widower denied social security benefits appeals decision
    • ABQ widower from same-sex marriage denied social security benefits

    View all Anthony Gonzales articles →

    • Cannabis class action suit over insurance moves to federal court

      A class action lawsuit challenging health insurance companies’ refusal to cover the costs of medical cannabis has been moved to federal court, for now.  The lawsuit, filed earlier this year by a group of medical cannabis patients and one cannabis production company, originally asked a state district court judge to order New Mexico healthcare insurance companies to cover the costs of medical cannabis for members. The seven insurance providers in turn refiled the case in federal court, arguing that it is the appropriate venue because the plaintiffs’ claims are inherently tied to federal law.  In June, six New Mexico medical cannabis patients and cannabis producer Ultra Health filed the class action suit, arguing that the recent enaction of a state law requiring insurance providers to cover the costs of behavioral health services should also include medical cannabis.

    • ICE ordered to release detained Iraqi refugees, including one New Mexican
    • READ: State's incomplete report on alleged SNAP fraud within HSD

    View all federal court articles →

    • Lujan Grisham bill would allow benefits for same sex couples who could not legally wed

      U.S. Rep. Michelle Lujan Grisham introduced a bill Friday that would amend the Social Security Act  to include some married, same sex couples that currently do not qualify for survivor’s benefits. Named for an Albuquerque resident, the Anthony Gonzales Equality for Survivors (AGES) Act, the bill would add alternatives for those who were not married for the minimum nine months in order to receive their deceased partner’s benefits.

    • Legislators want DOJ to probe behavioral health shakeup
    • ABQ widower from same-sex marriage denied social security benefits

    View all Mark Johnson articles →

    • U.S. House passes equality bill, but future uncertain

      With bipartisan support, the U.S. House of Representatives passed legislation to enshrine marriage equality into legislation on Tuesday by repealing the Defense of Marriage Act. The House voted 267 in favor with 157 Republicans voting no.

    • ABQ widower denied social security benefits appeals decision
    • Constitution meant to be followed

    View all Same sex marriage articles →

    • Lujan Grisham bill would allow benefits for same sex couples who could not legally wed

      U.S. Rep. Michelle Lujan Grisham introduced a bill Friday that would amend the Social Security Act  to include some married, same sex couples that currently do not qualify for survivor’s benefits. Named for an Albuquerque resident, the Anthony Gonzales Equality for Survivors (AGES) Act, the bill would add alternatives for those who were not married for the minimum nine months in order to receive their deceased partner’s benefits.

    • ABQ widower denied social security benefits appeals decision
    • Lujan Grisham wants Social Security office move delayed

    View all Social Security Administration articles →

    Previous article
    Oil boom in southern New Mexico ignites groundwater feud with Texas
    Next article
    For contracts, New Mexico increasingly looks elsewhere: Analysis finds growing reliance on out-of-state vendors

    Join the Conversation on Twitter

    My Tweets

    Newsroom

    • Environmental advocacy groups decry SCOTUS Clean Water Act ruling
      By Hannah Grover | May 26, 2023

      Environmental advocacy groups say that a U.S. Supreme Court ruling weakening the Clean Water Act will put waters throughout the country at risk of pollution and degradation.  The ruling requires a more stringent test to determine if wetlands are protected under the decades-old law.

    • ECECD will soon see a nearly 68 percent increase in funding
      By Susan Dunlap | May 26, 2023

      On July 1, a constitutional amendment to increase the distribution from the Land Grant Permanent Fund t toward educating the state’s youngest children goes into effect.

    • As climate changes, researchers develop a new metric for evaluating water available from snowpack
      By Hannah Grover | May 25, 2023

      Throughout the western United States, communities rely on the storage of water in mountain snowpack to feed the rivers and reservoirs that provide drinking water and irrigation supplies.

    #NMLEG

    • CYFD logo
      CYFD: Repeat maltreatment in decline, but higher than average
      By Susan Dunlap | May 25, 2023

      New Mexico has 360 more repeat child maltreatment cases annually than the national average.

    • Legislative report: Homelessness on the rise in New Mexico
      By Susan Dunlap | May 24, 2023

      Preliminary estimates for 2023 show a “significant uptick” of about 48 percent in homelessness in New Mexico, suggesting an increased need for affordable housing around the state, according to a report.

    Recent Posts

    • Santa Fe Roundhouse
      LFC reports $3.1 billion in outstanding capital outlay funds

      A legislative report found about $3.1 billion in unused capital outlay funds for FY23’s third quarter.  This is according to the Legislative Finance Committee’s quarterly capital outlay reports, which were presented by LFC analyst Cally Carswell on May 23.

    • Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham speaks during a press conference announcing the re-establishment of the Organized Crime Commission.
      Gov reestablishes organized crime commission

      Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced on Wednesday that she reestablished a multi-agency Organized Crime Commission.

    • LFC report says New Mexico economy doing well, for now

      The New Mexico economy, as of May 23, is doing well.

    © Copyright 2015-2023, NM Political Report

    This site built with Project Largo from INN and proudly powered by WordPress.

    Back to top ↑

    Follow

    Anthony Gonzales
    AndyLyman