Critics say PNM, Avangrid merger could hurt ratepayers, environment

Government entities, utilities and watchdog groups say a merger between Public Service Company of New Mexico and Avangrid could harm both ratepayers and the environment unless protections are included. These entities filed testimony in a New Mexico Public Regulation Commission case evaluating the merger. This merger is subject to the PRC approval as well as […]

Critics say PNM, Avangrid merger could hurt ratepayers, environment

Government entities, utilities and watchdog groups say a merger between Public Service Company of New Mexico and Avangrid could harm both ratepayers and the environment unless protections are included.

These entities filed testimony in a New Mexico Public Regulation Commission case evaluating the merger. This merger is subject to the PRC approval as well as approval from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.

PNM’s parent company, PNM Resources, is seeking to merge with Avangrid, a U.S. subsidiary of renewable energy giant Iberdrola, which is based in Spain.

The PRC hearings related to the merger are scheduled to start on May 3 and testimony has been filed expressing a variety of concerns.

“Our proposed merger transaction with Avangrid, a national leader in renewable energy, will help realize New Mexico’s clean energy potential,” said Kelly Renae-Huber, a spokesperson for PNM, in an emailed statement to NM Political Report. “The New Mexico Public Regulation Commission’s regulatory process ensures that our merger will benefit customers and the State of New Mexico. We believe that each of the intervening parties in this regulatory process shares with us an interest in our state’s future. We look forward to working with them throughout the proceeding.”

PNM and Avangrid have reached an agreement with some of the parties that initially said more protection was needed including the New Mexico Attorney General’s Office, Western Resource Advocates, Dine Citizens Against Ruining our Environment, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 611, San Juan Citizens Alliance, Tó Nizhóní Ání and Nava Education Project.

The stipulation filed on this week increases the local representation on the PNM Board of Directors, requires that following the merger PNM will hire a chief environmental officer and increases the amount of rate credits customers will receive.

Not all the opponents signed on to the stipulation. New Energy Economy Executive Director Mariel Nanasi argued that it goes against the precedent set when El Paso Electric was acquired by a fund tied to J.P. Morgan Chase.

One of the conditions from the El Paso case required the board of directors to be made up by a majority independent directors. While the majority of the PNM Board of Directors would be New Mexico residents under the stipulation, they could still be financially connected to PNM or Avangrid. Only 40 percent of them would be independent directors.

Customers could see a credit on their bill, but critics say it might not offset potential rate increases

While detractors expressed a range of concerns, one common critique is that the merger will benefit shareholders and company executives more than it will ratepayers and that the various benefits touted in the application are not enough to offset the risk.

For example, if the merger is approved, PNM customers will receive a credit on their bills. The merger application states this credit will be a total of $24.6 million that would be distributed over three years. This was increased to $50 million in the stipulation.

Nanasi said that credit will not mean much if the rates increase as a result of the merger.

Nanasi is not alone in that feeling.

“The rate credit is minuscule compared to the risk the ratepayers are assuming with this transaction,”  Mark Garrett, a consultant for Albuquerque Bernalillo County Water Users Authority, stated in testimony filed with the PRC.

He recommended a rate credit of between $126 and $226 million, which is about half of what Avangrid would pay above market value for the PNM Resources stocks.

The proposed $24.6 million rate credit will amount to very little on ratepayers bills, according to filed testimony. This is especially true for residential ratepayers because the credit would be based on usage rather than a per-customer basis.

Andrea Crane, a witness for the New Mexico Office of the Attorney General, said in her testimony that the rate credits for customers should be increased to a total of $85 million that should be distributed on a per-customer basis.

If distributed on a per-customer basis, the $24.6 million rate credit would be approximately $1.27 per month on each ratepayer’s bill. However, Crane pointed out that the credit would be based on the amount of energy used. Crane said while 90 percent of PNM’s customers are residential, they would only receive 38 percent of the rate credit, or about $0.55 per month. 

Natural Resources Defense Council Director of the Western Region Climate and Clean Energy Program Noah Long argued that PNM and Avangrid should provide more for low-income customers who were disproportionately impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic.

“Avangrid is not just acquiring stock in a company, it is acquiring an obligation to serve its New Mexico customers with reliable, clean energy and just and reasonable rates,” Long said in his testimony. “Low-income customers make up a substantial share of PNM customers. Shareholders profited while low-income customers struggled to access and pay for the essential commodity of electricity. In many cases, these customers’ health, safety and very lives were jeopardized as they figured out ways to keep bills low, how to juggle the little they had to pay something that might prevent disconnection, and how to meet unreasonable and unnecessary documentation demands to prove indigency and get some ‘help’ in paying arrears. Now shareholders stand to receive an acquisition premium of hundreds of millions of dollars. It is only fair, just and reasonable, to share some of this wealth that was created by New Mexico ratepayers, including the neediest amongst them.”  

While the PRC has implemented a moratorium on disconnections for non-payment, regulators are encouraging customers to enter into payment arrangements as those bills will eventually become due.

Long also requested that PNM and Avangrid commit at least $25 million to expanding access to reliable electricity in New Mexico.

The stipulation filed this week commits $2 million to expanding access and provides $6 million to assist customers who were unable to pay their bills due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Los Alamos County witness says merger should be contingent upon the “timely decommissioning” of the San Juan Generating Station

A California utility that previously owned a share of the San Juan Generating Station partnered with Los Alamos County, a current owner of the power plant, stating that actions taken could adversely impact their customers as well.

Energy consultant David Arthur’s testimony on behalf of M-S-R Public Power Agency, based in Modesto, California, and Los Alamos County states that the merger should be contingent upon the timely decommissioning of the San Juan Generating Station, which PNM has proposed to retire in place. That means that the plant would not be demolished for at least 20 years. PNM argues that this will save ratepayers money.

Arthur stated that the decommissioning agreement that the various owners of the power plant signed “does not expressly provide for a retirement in place scenario” and does not provide a means for recovering costs from remaining parties should they suffer from insufficient revenue to decommission the plant. He said the operation and maintenance costs will increase as the structures deteriorate overtime and the value for the scrap material will decrease.

He argued that delaying the decommissioning provides a short-term win for the current PNM ratepayers but could lead to higher costs for future customers who never benefited from the power generated by the San Juan Generating Station. 

In addition, Arthur stated that the delay in decommissioning could lead to financial risks for the other power plant owners. If the price of decommissioning increases overtime, the other owners could have to pay more in the future. This could lead to ratepayers in Los Alamos County and in California picking up the tab.

Concerns that PNM could squash competition in the renewable energy market

Larry Blank, a New Mexico State University faculty member who is also a consultant in utility industry policy, provided testimony on behalf of the City of Albuquerque. He expressed concerns in his testimony that PNM and Avangrid could use the size of the merged companies to essentially quash renewable energy development that does not belong to Avangrid. This could come in the form of rejecting bids from non-Avangrid related companies for generation assets.

“When significant amounts of money are at stake, there is a strong profit incentive to favor an affiliate over other suppliers in the market,” Blank stated. “This bias may be implemented through the choice of technologies or type of power to be procured, the design of the request for proposals, the evaluation criteria used to assess proposals, and other design details within the procurement process. There is also the concern that commercially sensitive proprietary data may be leaked from the regulated utility to the competitive affiliate.”

This could lead to higher costs for power, Blank states.

“We are at a critical stage of development in New Mexico in which the planning and procurement of alternative power supply is very important to our future and the potential success of attaining the zero-carbon goal required by the REA (Renewable Energy Act),” he continued in the testimony. “New technologies will likely be emerging for the production and storage of renewable energy. Any favoritism toward the technology provided by an affiliate would stifle adoption of the most innovative ways to meet our goals.”

AG’s witness says PNM shouldn’t seek financing for Four Corners Power Plant transfer if the merger is approved

The Four Corners Power Plant is pictured, Monday, April 19, 2021, in Upper Fruitland.

One issue at the heart of the merger is the transfer of the Four Corners Power Plant to Navajo Transitional Energy Company. This transfer of ownership was needed because Avangrid does not want to be a long-term owner of a coal-fired power plant. But, by transferring the ownership, environmental advocates say PNM forfeits its ability to vote to close the power plant early and NTEC would likely want to continue operations. That means that while PNM would not have any coal in its portfolio, the emissions related to the power plant would continue to impact San Juan County.

PNM has filed an application with the PRC to transfer the ownership of the power plant. As part of this application, it is asking to refinance past investments into the plant at a lower interest rate. This process is known as securitization and was used when PNM filed to end its operations of the nearby San Juan Generating Station. The low interest bonds used to refinance the debt are paid off using a non-bypassable charge on customer bills. Some critics, such as New Energy Economy, argue that the shareholders should pay for the past investments into the power plant, especially if these investments were not prudent. The PRC is currently evaluating if the past investments into the power plant were prudent as part of the transfer case.

But Crane argues in her testimony that PNM should withdraw its request for securitization as a condition of the merger.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

Lujan Grisham pocket vetoes two bills

Lujan Grisham pocket vetoes two bills

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham pocket vetoed two bills the legislature passed this legislative session: one changing the Cybersecurity Act and the other concerning law…
Gov signs bills with some vetoes 

Gov signs bills with some vetoes 

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham signed 69 bills that the legislature passed during the 2024 legislative session. These included the General Appropriations Act which contains…
Guv signs state budget

Guv signs state budget

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham signed the budget bill for Fiscal Year 2025 and the Capital Outlay spending bill. The FY25 state budget bill passed…
Advocates travel to D.C. to push for additional protections for the Gila River

Advocates travel to D.C. to push for additional protections for the Gila River

New Mexico advocates seeking to have the Gila River designated as a Wild and Scenic River will travel to Washington D.C. this week to…

NM Supreme Court annuls $10,000 penalty in PNM/Avangrid merger case

The New Mexico Supreme Court ruled on Monday that a penalty the New Mexico Public Regulation Commission levied against the state’s largest utility was…
State fines oil company more than $2 million after spill

State fines oil company more than $2 million after spill

The Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department fined an oil and gas company operating in the Permian Basin more than $2 million over produced…
Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican The main things that bring Brayan Chavez to school every day: Seeing, talking to and engaging with…
Special ed teachers hope lawmakers OK pay raises, admin changes

Special ed teachers hope lawmakers OK pay raises, admin changes

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican Brittany Behenna Griffith has a laundry list of adjectives to describe the ideal special education teacher:…
Lawmakers must find consensus on competing education spending plans

Lawmakers must find consensus on competing education spending plans

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican A challenging task awaits New Mexico lawmakers in the next 30 days: Reconciling three very different…
Lujan Grisham, Biden admin announce $10 million in federal funds for tribes, pueblos

Lujan Grisham, Biden admin announce $10 million in federal funds for tribes, pueblos

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced Friday $10 million in funding from the federal American Rescue Plan Act was awarded to six tribal nations and…
Proposal to curb executive powers moves to House Judiciary

Proposal to curb executive powers moves to House Judiciary

The House Government, Elections and Indian Affairs Committee discussed a potential constitutional amendment that seeks to limit the governor’s executive powers. The committee approved…
Supreme Court censures attorney over conduct in anti-COVID policy suits

Supreme Court censures attorney over conduct in anti-COVID policy suits

The New Mexico State Supreme Court censured a New Mexico attorney because of her “misconduct” in two unsuccessful cases pushing back on COVID-19 regulations…
Supreme Court to hear two abortion cases this spring

Supreme Court to hear two abortion cases this spring

Later this month, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on the case against the abortion medication mifepristone. It will hear a second…
How Biden, others highlighted reproductive rights at the State of the Union

How Biden, others highlighted reproductive rights at the State of the Union

President Joe Biden highlighted reproductive rights issues as part of his State of the Union speech Thursday. Biden delivered his 2024 State of the…
Stansbury invites OB-GYN doctor as her state of the union guest 

Stansbury invites OB-GYN doctor as her state of the union guest 

U.S. House of Rep. Melanie Stansbury has invited an OB-GYN doctor from Roswell as her guest for President Joe Biden’s State of the Union…
Supreme Court to hear two abortion cases this spring

Supreme Court to hear two abortion cases this spring

Later this month, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on the case against the abortion medication mifepristone. It will hear a second…
How Biden, others highlighted reproductive rights at the State of the Union

How Biden, others highlighted reproductive rights at the State of the Union

President Joe Biden highlighted reproductive rights issues as part of his State of the Union speech Thursday. Biden delivered his 2024 State of the…
Stansbury invites OB-GYN doctor as her state of the union guest 

Stansbury invites OB-GYN doctor as her state of the union guest 

U.S. House of Rep. Melanie Stansbury has invited an OB-GYN doctor from Roswell as her guest for President Joe Biden’s State of the Union…
See who’s going to be on your primary ballot in June

See who’s going to be on your primary ballot in June

Tuesday marked the official beginning of the 2024 New Mexico primary season for the legislature, with candidates officially filing for candidacy. This is the…

Bill to require disclosure of use of AI in campaign materials goes to governor

The Senate approved a bill aiming to require the disclosure of the use of artificial intelligence or other changes made by computers to campaign…
House amends, passes bill banning firearms near polling places

House amends, passes bill banning firearms near polling places

The House narrowly approved a bill that would ban firearms near polling places. The House voted 35-34 to pass the bill following an extensive…
Advocates travel to D.C. to push for additional protections for the Gila River

Advocates travel to D.C. to push for additional protections for the Gila River

New Mexico advocates seeking to have the Gila River designated as a Wild and Scenic River will travel to Washington D.C. this week to…
U.S. Supreme Court lets ban on Couy Griffin from holding office stand

U.S. Supreme Court lets ban on Couy Griffin from holding office stand

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal of a Republican official who was barred from holding office after being convicted for a…
Politics Newsletter: legislative leaders not running for reelection

Politics Newsletter: legislative leaders not running for reelection

Hello fellow political junkies! Candidate filing day has come and gone, and members of House and Senate leadership opted to either not seek reelection…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report