Employees say HSD asked them to falsify SNAP applications

Multiple state employees alleged that the Human Services Department instructed them to falsify numbers on federal food stamp applications in explosive testimonies in federal court in Albuquerque Thursday afternoon. One was Jeannette Roybal, who processes Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, applications in Las Cruces. She testified that her supervisor told her in January to […]

Employees say HSD asked them to falsify SNAP applications

Multiple state employees alleged that the Human Services Department instructed them to falsify numbers on federal food stamp applications in explosive testimonies in federal court in Albuquerque Thursday afternoon.

Federal Courthouse in Albuquerque Photo: Andy Lyman
Federal Courthouse in Albuquerque Photo: Andy Lyman

One was Jeannette Roybal, who processes Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, applications in Las Cruces. She testified that her supervisor told her in January to inflate the assets of a SNAP applicant so the application would be considered non-expeditable.

Related: NM Auditor, HSD launch probes into SNAP fraud allegations

According to federal law, those who qualify for expedited SNAP benefits based on extremely low income levels must receive their benefits within seven days of applying. These are also known as emergency SNAP benefits. But many of these cases that appeared to qualify weren’t resolved by HSD within that amount of time, leading to overdue cases, according to multiple testimonies.

“There were no resources in the case to add,” Roybal said before court. “It’s not the proper way.”

Sandra Saiz, a line manager for Income Support Division in Portales, testified that higher-ups encouraged her workplace to add fake assets to SNAP applications so the department could cut down its growing list of overdue expedited SNAP cases.

“The directive was to do whatever you had to make it non-expedite,” Saiz said in her testimony.

Usually, that meant trying to “find something you missed somewhere” in the application for benefits, according to Saiz. But when asked by a state lawyer she ever made up a number to add to an application, she replied: “I very seldom do it, I don’t like to do it, but yes, I have done it.”

The testimony came during a hearing for a legal motion asking for HSD to be held in contempt of court for not complying with provisions in a 25-year-old consent decree. The consent decree was the result of a lawsuit that alleged the department didn’t process food stamp and Medicaid applications properly.

The New Mexico Center on Law and Poverty is asking federal court to appoint an independent monitor to oversee several HSD functions, including ISD.

The directive for the Portales ISD office came from the office’s regional office manager in April 2015, according to case processor Angela Dominguez.

“He came and said they had been selected for federal review,” Dominguez said during testimony. “He was concerned how we were going to justify [the overdue expedited cases]. He said, ‘You can go in there and check and add assets.’”

Adding assets, Dominguez said, would expand the time period HSD had to process these cases. But that means people who qualify for expedited SNAP benefits won’t receive them.

“In my opinion we’re cheating those families,” Dominguez said in her testimony.

HSD management went as far as to change a processor’s case notes to show that they reflected adding assets to an application, according to Margaret Vasquez-Padilla, who works at ISD in Taos. Vasquez-Padilla testified that she processed an overdue expedited SNAP case that her superiors later added $400 in assets to.

“How did they reflect $400 in assets?” Sovereign Hager, an attorney for Center on Law and Poverty, asked during the hearing.

“They just put them there,” Vasquez-Padilla replied.

Vasquez-Padilla said she knew her superiors changed her case notes on the application. She said she kept her old case notes “because this has happened before.”

Another ISD employee, Frederick Garcia, testified that he knew employees would add fake assets to SNAP applications.

“I’ll see it quoted as ‘cash on hand,” Garcia, who works in Las Cruces, said.

During testimony, HSD Secretary Brent Earnest argued that resorting to an independent monitor, known as a receivership, “seems like a recipe for chaos.” Earnest said such measures would cost money that could otherwise go to the poor.

Addressing the lawsuit as a whole, Earnest acknowledged that he “makes mistakes” and that “everyone in the department is going to make mistakes” but that HSD “has a way to address them.”

Shanita Harrison, a deputy director for ISD, addressed the employees’ allegations by accusing four of those who testified about the fake assets of making errors on their cases.

During her own testimony, Harrison accused Garcia of marking a SNAP case as expedited that didn’t qualify because the family involved “received benefits in Alabama during the month of their application.”

Harrison also accused Dominguez of processing a case that was not expedited because the family had $2,200 in income.

She alleged Vasquez-Padilla made an error by processing a renewal application as a new application. Finally, Harrison accused Roybal of not properly updating the data on one of her cases.

All five employees who testified said they feared retaliation for coming forward.

Closing arguments for the legal motion will likely happen next week, after which the federal judge will decide on whether to appoint an independent monitor to oversee these parts of HSD.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

Perhaps the most vilified population in the United States during the first Trump Administration were immigrants. This vilification is only rising. Trump plans to…
State Rep. Alcon steps down, cites health concerns

State Rep. Alcon steps down, cites health concerns

State Rep. Eliseo “Lee” Alcon, D-Milan, announced his retirement from the legislature Saturday citing health issues as the reason. The retirement was effective immediately.…
Politics Newsletter: potential immigration legislation

Politics Newsletter: potential immigration legislation

Hello fellow political junkies! New Mexico immigrant advocacy groups announced their legislative proposals during a press conference Nov. 22. The proposals include not allowing…
PNM plans to build a new solar facility in northwest New Mexico

PNM plans to build a new solar facility in northwest New Mexico

A new solar and battery storage facility known as the Sunbelt Project could be coming to the Central Consolidated School District in northwest New…
NM launches phase two of rebate program on Black Friday

NM launches phase two of rebate program on Black Friday

People looking to upgrade to new energy-efficient appliances may be in luck this Black Friday. The New Mexico Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department…
NMED releases final strategic water supply feasibility study

NMED releases final strategic water supply feasibility study

More details are now available about a controversial plan to use treated produced and brackish water for industrial purposes. Produced water is a byproduct…
Head Start could be threatened under Trump

Head Start could be threatened under Trump

A popular program that enjoys bipartisan support, Head Start, could be under threat under a second Donald Trump administration. Project 2025 calls for the…
MLG speaks about education during oil, gas industry meeting

MLG speaks about education during oil, gas industry meeting

New Mexico produces the second highest amount of oil and gas in the country. The taxes from oil and gas production provide funding for…
Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

About 200 people from tribal governors to legislators to advocates and teachers gathered at Bishop’s Lodge to discuss Early Childhood Education’s future in New…
Heinrich introduces legislation to address affordable housing

Heinrich introduces legislation to address affordable housing

U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich, D-New Mexico, introduced legislation in the Senate on Monday that would provide tax credits to incentivize new investments and additional…
New Mexico in critical nursing shortage

New Mexico in critical nursing shortage

With 8,800 nurse positions posted for hiring in New Mexico, hospital leadership told the Legislative Health and Human Services Committee on Tuesday that access…
As rhetoric around undocumented workers heats up, new report shows their tax contribution

As rhetoric around undocumented workers heats up, new report shows their tax contribution

A nonprofit group released data showing how much taxes migrants pay in the U.S. as rhetoric on immigration grows more prominent just months from…
Abortion care: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

Abortion care: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

With a Republican trifecta going forward, the right to an abortion and the ability to obtain one will be at high risk even in…
Indigenous Women Rising rebrands amid decrease in donations and increased costs

Indigenous Women Rising rebrands amid decrease in donations and increased costs

Indigenous Women Rising, a grassroots abortion fund provider supporting Native individuals, is experiencing a decrease in donations while, simultaneously, an increase in those needing…
U.S. Supreme Court has one bodily autonomy case on its docket

U.S. Supreme Court has one bodily autonomy case on its docket

With the U.S. Supreme Court refusing to hear one reproductive rights case this term, the high court has only one case on its docket…
Stansbury announces bill to expand medical residencies in Tribal communities

Stansbury announces bill to expand medical residencies in Tribal communities

U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury introduced a bill that would provide $4 million annually to create an office within the Indian Health Service to oversee…
Sexual assault helpline launches during Domestic Violence Awareness Month

Sexual assault helpline launches during Domestic Violence Awareness Month

A new, dedicated statewide sexual assault helpline officially went live on Monday. The New Mexico Coalition of Sexual Assault Programs launched the helpline to…
Golden Opportunity to use community collaboration to battle opioid epidemic

Golden Opportunity to use community collaboration to battle opioid epidemic

The opioid epidemic is easing in the Albuquerque area and more help is on the way, according to the New Mexico Department of Health.…
New Mexico completes election canvass, two recounts triggered

New Mexico completes election canvass, two recounts triggered

The State Canvass Board certified the New Mexico 2024 general election results Tuesday in Santa Fe. The board, comprised of Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham,…
LGBTQ rights: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

LGBTQ rights: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

Within the first two days after the general election earlier this month, LGBTQ crisis lines in the U.S. experienced a 700 percent increase in…
Politics Newsletter: Election recap

Politics Newsletter: Election recap

Hello fellow political junkies! The election is over (finally) but the work of government continues as does the work of covering and chronicling the…
Artificial Intelligence regulation under Trump

Artificial Intelligence regulation under Trump

As artificial intelligence becomes more commonplace, Congress is attempting to put in place some regulations designed to mitigate against potential risks. Proponents of the…
Trump likely to change regs protecting against sex-based discrimination in schools

Trump likely to change regs protecting against sex-based discrimination in schools

President-elect Donald Trump is likely to return the regulation, Title IX, that protects against sex-based discrimination, to previous rules which could harm LGBTQ individuals…
‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

Perhaps the most vilified population in the United States during the first Trump Administration were immigrants. This vilification is only rising. Trump plans to…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report