NM Supreme Court upholds constitutional amendment changing PRC to an appointed body

Despite arguments that voters did not understand that they would lose the ability to elect state utility regulators, the New Mexico Supreme Court upheld the constitutional amendment that changes the New Mexico Public Regulation Commission from an elected body to an appointed body. The court heard oral arguments on Monday and, after a brief recess, […]

NM Supreme Court upholds constitutional amendment changing PRC to an appointed body

Despite arguments that voters did not understand that they would lose the ability to elect state utility regulators, the New Mexico Supreme Court upheld the constitutional amendment that changes the New Mexico Public Regulation Commission from an elected body to an appointed body.

The court heard oral arguments on Monday and, after a brief recess, the judges returned to the room and announced their decision. A written opinion will be issued that explains the reasoning.

The change goes into effect in January and a nominating committee is currently considering about fifteen candidates. The nominating committee meets Friday and is expected to choose which names to submit to the governor for consideration. 

The Indigenous groups argue that the appointment rather than election of PRC commissioners will disenfranchise them by potentially eliminating representation. They pointed specifically to District Four, which comprises northwestern New Mexico. District Four is a predominantly Native American district and has been at the center of many of the more controversial decisions the PRC has made in recent years. District Four has typically been an energy powerhouse for the state and is home to the shuttered Escalante Generating Station and San Juan Generating Station, which were both coal-fired power plants. The only remaining coal-fired power plant, the Four Corners Power Plant, is also within District Four.

Was the petition timely?

The timing of the case was one of the central points of discussion on Monday. A trio of Indigenous groups challenged the constitutionality of the change based on the ballot language in late August. The groups said the ballot language did not make it clear that voters would lose representation. 

“We’re here today on the eve of the transition to the PRC because petitioners waited two years to challenge the results of a democratically-held election,” Kyle Duffy, an attorney for the governor’s office, said.

The governor’s office intervened in the case.

The constitutional amendment passed during the November 2020 election. The appointed body will consist of three commissioners rather than five commissioners. The new PRC will not be divided into districts, which means the commissioners could conceivably all live in metropolitan areas like Albuquerque or Santa Fe.

In general, the election code allows for a 30-day window of time when people can challenge the results of an election. 

Justice David Thomson questioned arguments that the results should have been challenged within those 30 days.

“You’re basically putting a very short statute of limitation on the constitutional claim,” he said.

Chief Justice Shannon Bacon also questioned the argument that even if the ballot language was unconstitutional, the fact that it wasn’t challenged within 30 days means that it cannot be challenged now. She described that as a “pretty extreme position to tell the Supreme Court of the State of New Mexico to turn a blind eye to that which might be unconstitutional.”

Sarah Shore, an attorney for the Indigenous groups, said that in certain instances there are time limitations to challenging constitutional amendments after an election occurs.

“But this is not that case. The main effect of the amendment hasn’t gone into effect,” she said. “A constitutional right was repealed from the people and this court is the only recourse that people have in a circumstance like this.”

Did the ballot measure consist of confusing language, logrolling?

In addition to calling the ballot language confusing, the petitioners described the measure as logrolling—or pairing unpopular measures with a popular measure in an attempt to get the unpopular measures passed.

“It’s illuminating to go through how many things are missing from this ballot question, including which parts of the constitution are being modified, the repeal of an existing right to vote, the repeal of an existing right to geographic representation, the repeal of large areas of the PRC’s constitutional jurisdiction,” Shore said. 

She said she isn’t arguing that every single omitted detail should have been included in the ballot language, but that the repeal of the right to vote for commissioners from geographical districts of New Mexico should have been.

The ballot language came from the legislation passed that enabled the constitutional amendment to be placed on the ballot.

Thomson said a lot of the concerns surround what language was not in the constitutional amendment on the ballot.

He said the petitioners argue that “if you are going to take an existing right, that is the right to elect rather than the governor to appoint, that must be specifically spelled out.”

However, Thomson said he could not find any authority for that argument.

Duffy said that while the ballot question did not say that voters would lose the right to vote for members of the PRC, it was implicit that if the governor was picking the commissioners, the voters would not be.

“I don’t think that this is a case where the legislature was hiding the ball,” he said.

Duffy said the petitioners did not provide evidence that any voter was misled and that nearly 100,000 voters would have had to have been misled to alter the results of the election.

Justice Brianna Zamora asked Shore about whether specific evidence that voters were misled should be required rather than just speculation.

Shore said that it isn’t just speculation. She said the court needs to ask what the average voter would have understood from the wording.

In terms of logrolling, Justice Michael Vigil read the ballot language out loud during the oral arguments.

“It seems to me that there are three separate independent proposals in that title,” he said.

But Duffy argued that all the proposals were connected by the single main purpose of reforming the PRC.

Zamora asked why it wasn’t logrolling if a voter supported part of the measure, such as reducing the number of commissioners and limiting its jurisdiction, but opposed giving up the right to elect the commissioners.

“That could be argued in almost any constitutional amendment,” Duffy said. “It’s very rare that there’s just one explicit change in the amendment.”

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

Emily’s List endorses seven candidates for Legislature

Emily’s List endorses seven candidates for Legislature

Emily’s List, a nonprofit that supports women candidates and reproductive rights, endorsed seven incumbents facing general election opponents in New Mexico legislative elections. All…
Equality New Mexico endorses 15 legislative candidates

Equality New Mexico endorses 15 legislative candidates

A New Mexico-based LGBTQ rights organization endorsed 15 candidates for state House and Senate seats for the 2024 elections.  Marshall Martinez, executive director of…
Lujan Grisham pocket vetoes two bills

Lujan Grisham pocket vetoes two bills

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham pocket vetoed two bills the legislature passed this legislative session: one changing the Cybersecurity Act and the other concerning law…
BLM increases what companies must pay to extract oil and gas 

BLM increases what companies must pay to extract oil and gas 

The U.S. Bureau of Land Management announced a new rule Friday governing onshore oil and gas production that advocacy groups say will help protect…
Court hears arguments in oil and gas pollution case

Court hears arguments in oil and gas pollution case

A district court judge heard arguments Friday about whether to dismiss a lawsuit that could have major implications for the oil and gas industry…
Feds announce final renewable energy rule for public lands

Feds announce final renewable energy rule for public lands

The U.S. Department of the Interior announced a final renewable energy rule Thursday that is expected to pave the way for increased wind, solar…
Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican The main things that bring Brayan Chavez to school every day: Seeing, talking to and engaging with…
Special ed teachers hope lawmakers OK pay raises, admin changes

Special ed teachers hope lawmakers OK pay raises, admin changes

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican Brittany Behenna Griffith has a laundry list of adjectives to describe the ideal special education teacher:…
Lawmakers must find consensus on competing education spending plans

Lawmakers must find consensus on competing education spending plans

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican A challenging task awaits New Mexico lawmakers in the next 30 days: Reconciling three very different…
Health workers fear it’s profits before protection as CDC revisits airborne transmission

Health workers fear it’s profits before protection as CDC revisits airborne transmission

Amy Maxmen, KFF Health News Four years after hospitals in New York City overflowed with covid-19 patients, emergency physician Sonya Stokes remains shaken by…
Lujan Grisham, Biden admin announce $10 million in federal funds for tribes, pueblos

Lujan Grisham, Biden admin announce $10 million in federal funds for tribes, pueblos

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced Friday $10 million in funding from the federal American Rescue Plan Act was awarded to six tribal nations and…
Proposal to curb executive powers moves to House Judiciary

Proposal to curb executive powers moves to House Judiciary

The House Government, Elections and Indian Affairs Committee discussed a potential constitutional amendment that seeks to limit the governor’s executive powers. The committee approved…
How the AZ Supreme Court decision on abortion impacts New Mexico

How the AZ Supreme Court decision on abortion impacts New Mexico

The Arizona Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday that an 1864 abortion ban is enforceable, throwing another state bordering New Mexico into the situation of…
The status of the lawsuit New Mexico joined to remove FDA restrictions to mifepristone

The status of the lawsuit New Mexico joined to remove FDA restrictions to mifepristone

While the U.S. Supreme Court considers the future of access to the abortion medication, mifepristone, another lawsuit against the FDA that would expand access…
Senators introduce legislation to aid abortion providers

Senators introduce legislation to aid abortion providers

Sen. Martin Heinrih and other Senate colleagues introduced abortion rights legislation into the U.S. Senate on Thursday. The Abortion Care Capacity Enhancement and Support…
How the AZ Supreme Court decision on abortion impacts New Mexico

How the AZ Supreme Court decision on abortion impacts New Mexico

The Arizona Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday that an 1864 abortion ban is enforceable, throwing another state bordering New Mexico into the situation of…
The status of the lawsuit New Mexico joined to remove FDA restrictions to mifepristone

The status of the lawsuit New Mexico joined to remove FDA restrictions to mifepristone

While the U.S. Supreme Court considers the future of access to the abortion medication, mifepristone, another lawsuit against the FDA that would expand access…
Senators introduce legislation to aid abortion providers

Senators introduce legislation to aid abortion providers

Sen. Martin Heinrih and other Senate colleagues introduced abortion rights legislation into the U.S. Senate on Thursday. The Abortion Care Capacity Enhancement and Support…
Politics Newsletter: Early and absentee voting

Politics Newsletter: Early and absentee voting

Good morning fellow political junkies! Early and absentee voting for the June 4 New Mexico primary begins in about a month. The nonprofit election…
San Juan County, Navajo Nation settle redistricting case

San Juan County, Navajo Nation settle redistricting case

The Navajo Nation and San Juan County reached an agreement Monday about commission districts after the tribe alleged that its members were not adequately…
MIT ranks NM elections most well-run in the U.S.

MIT ranks NM elections most well-run in the U.S.

New Mexico’s 2022 election was ranked most well-run in the country by Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Election Data and Science Lab’s Elections Performance Index.…
BLM increases what companies must pay to extract oil and gas 

BLM increases what companies must pay to extract oil and gas 

The U.S. Bureau of Land Management announced a new rule Friday governing onshore oil and gas production that advocacy groups say will help protect…
What the low unemployment rates for months means for NM’s economy

What the low unemployment rates for months means for NM’s economy

Post-pandemic, New Mexico has had an extended run of low unemployment rates. New Mexico’s unemployment rate has remained stable at 4.0 percent since October…
Feds announce final renewable energy rule for public lands

Feds announce final renewable energy rule for public lands

The U.S. Department of the Interior announced a final renewable energy rule Thursday that is expected to pave the way for increased wind, solar…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report