Push to resurrect board of education, eliminate PED secretary gains traction

By Daniel J. Chacón, The Santa Fe New Mexican Voters would be asked whether they want to resurrect a statewide board to oversee New Mexico’s beleaguered public schools under a proposed constitutional amendment the Senate Rules Committee endorsed Monday. Senate Joint Resolution 1 would eliminate the Cabinet position of public education secretary, and a 15-member […]

Push to resurrect board of education, eliminate PED secretary gains traction

By Daniel J. Chacón, The Santa Fe New Mexican

Voters would be asked whether they want to resurrect a statewide board to oversee New Mexico’s beleaguered public schools under a proposed constitutional amendment the Senate Rules Committee endorsed Monday.

Senate Joint Resolution 1 would eliminate the Cabinet position of public education secretary, and a 15-member board of education — including 10 elected members and five members appointed by the governor — would hire a state superintendent, who would direct the policies of the Public Education Department.

“We need stability in education, and that’s the bottom line on this” proposal, the lead sponsor, Republican Sen. Steven Neville of Aztec, told the Rules Committee. He cited the turnover of six public education secretaries since 2003, including three under Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham.

The proposed constitutional amendment would go before voters in 2024 if the Legislature passes SJR 1. If it is approved by voters, the election of new school board members would take place in 2026.

Neville’s original proposal called for 10 elected board members. A substitute version adds five appointed members, for a total of 15.

“We considered a different [substitute] where we would have seven [members] appointed by the governor, so this is kind of a compromise between the two concepts,” he said in an interview.

New Mexico used to have an elected state board of education. In 2003, voters approved a constitutional amendment establishing the Public Education Department, and responsibilities shifted from a superintendent of public instruction selected by the board to a secretary selected by the governor, according to a fiscal impact report.

Before voters approved that constitutional amendment, three superintendents served over the course of four to five decades, said Senate President Pro Tem Mimi Stewart, D-Albuquerque.

“We would be going back to those times where we had more consistency in education instead of the differing policies that happen between administrations,” she said.

Neville echoed the sentiment.

“We need to have a superintendent and a system in place that allows for something longer than a governor’s term, frankly,” he said. “It’s not faulting any single governor or whatever, but we change governors every four to eight years, no matter what, and if we change secretaries that often … then we would be looking at changing the whole system every eight years at a minimum. That’s just not a good way to run something as important as our schools.”

Stewart said the push to bring back a board of education has been proposed in the past.

But it hasn’t gained traction.

The latest proposal cleared the committee 6-1. Sen. Jerry Ortiz y Pino, D-Albuquerque, cast the lone dissenting vote.

“It’s a political question,” Stewart said about the proposed constitutional amendment. “It’s a philosophical suggestion that we go back to more stability than what we have now.”

Stan Rounds, executive director of the New Mexico Superintendents’ Association and the New Mexico Coalition of Education Leaders, spoke in favor of the proposal, arguing it would take the state back to a system that works better.

“We are concerned about stability,” he said.

Rounds noted a new board wouldn’t take office until after the end of Lujan Grisham’s second term.

“When it changes, it changes with a new administration, which allows us to finish our current trajectory under the current process and start fresh with a new change in governor,” he said.

A teachers union official agreed the state needs a more stable education system, but in an interview Monday she said a return to the one in place 20 years ago isn’t the right solution. 

Mary Parr Sanchez, president of the National Education Association of New Mexico,  said NEA supported the switch from a board and superintendent to a Cabinet secretary of education two decades ago because board members at the time often were gridlocked by lack of consensus and slow to change education policy.

Since then, she said, the education system has been subjected to upheaval with each change in the executive branch, generating “whiplash” in policy changes and leading to instability.

“People are just frustrated because there is a revolving door — as most people are aware of — of education folks, from the top position of the [department] secretary to the deputy secretary to the superintendents to the school principals to assistant principals to classroom teachers to school secretaries, on down the line. That does not make a stable system for our kids,” Parr Sanchez said.

She said she would rather see the department streamlined and its scope limited to essential statewide duties, with bolstered staffing at the top.

“I don’t know that the whole system has to change again, but something does need to change,” she said.

Amanda Aragon, executive director of the education advocacy organization New Mexico Kids CAN, also said the state’s public education system needs improvements, but she believes the state should focus on improving instruction and, therefore, educational outcomes, rather than restructuring the Public Education Department.

“There are 49 states ranked ahead of New Mexico, all with varied governance structures and all with education results far exceeding our own,” she wrote in an email. “New Mexico’s problem is not governance; it’s instruction. That’s where we should be putting our effort, improving instruction in New Mexico classrooms.”

Lobbyist J.D. Bullington, speaking on behalf of the Greater Albuquerque Chamber of Commerce, said the business group was among the leading proponents of the push under former Gov. Bill Richardson to move away from an elected state school board and shift the accountability to the governor.

“We do feel that that policy is sound,” he said. “Basically, the reason we moved away from an elected body was that it was perceived to just be too political in a very similar manner as the Public Regulation Commission, and we’ve now moved over to an appointed arrangement with that organization.”

Follow Daniel J. Chacón on Twitter @danieljchacon.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

Judge rules that congressional map is not an unlawful gerrymander

Judge rules that congressional map is not an unlawful gerrymander

A judge upheld the congressional maps that Republicans alleged included illegal gerrymandering, particularly in the case of the state’s 2nd Congressional District. Ninth Judicial…
Challenger announces she’ll run for Ivey-Soto Senate seat

Challenger announces she’ll run for Ivey-Soto Senate seat

Former New Mexico House Democratic Campaign Committee finance director Heather Berghmans announced her run for state senate District 15 on Thursday. She is running…
New law leads to confusion over IPRA while some inmate hearings hang in the balance

New law leads to confusion over IPRA while some inmate hearings hang in the balance

A new law that provides opportunity for adults who were sentenced as children to decades in prison to have a parole hearing after a…
U.S. reports record oil exports

U.S. reports record oil exports

The U.S. exported a record amount of oil during the first half of the year, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. During that…
State senator will look at geothermal legislation

State senator will look at geothermal legislation

After the governor vetoed legislation to support geothermal energy that received limited opposition from lawmakers during the legislative session was vetoed, Sen. Gerald Ortiz…
Legislation would end mineral leasing in the Upper Pecos watershed

Legislation would end mineral leasing in the Upper Pecos watershed

U.S. Senators Martin Heinrich and Ben Ray Luján introduced legislation that seeks to withdraw portions of the Pecos River watershed in northern New Mexico…
More learning time, free meals coming to students this school year

More learning time, free meals coming to students this school year

As children prepare to return to school for the new public school year, they will see some changes after legislation passed in the 2023…
Legislature hears about post-COVID impacts on education

Legislature hears about post-COVID impacts on education

Public education is still recovering from the effects of COVID-19 lockdowns. The state Legislative Finance Committee’s Public Education Subcommittee released a report Wednesday detailing…
ECECD hosts baby showers to let parents know about resources

ECECD hosts baby showers to let parents know about resources

Friday afternoon, a line of people formed outside a room in the Explora Science Center and Children’s Museum in Albuquerque.  The line was made…
Gov. Lujan Grisham tests positive for COVID

Gov. Lujan Grisham tests positive for COVID

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham tested positive for COVID-19 for a third time. The governor’s office said that Lujan Grisham is experiencing mild symptoms and…
Study: New Mexico had highest increase in abortion since 2020

Study: New Mexico had highest increase in abortion since 2020

Between January 2020 and June 2023, New Mexico saw a larger increase in abortion than any other state, according to a new report. The…
Doctors encourage vaccinations for respiratory illnesses, including COVID

Doctors encourage vaccinations for respiratory illnesses, including COVID

Health officials from hospitals throughout the state encouraged New Mexicans to get vaccinated against three respiratory illnesses, including COVID-19. After the U.S. Food and…
US Supreme Court expected to hear the abortion medication case this term

US Supreme Court expected to hear the abortion medication case this term

Two upcoming U.S. Supreme Court cases  this term could impact abortion rights and victims of domestic violence. The high court has not set a…
Indigenous Women Rising: Abortion fund budget has doubled since Dobbs

Indigenous Women Rising: Abortion fund budget has doubled since Dobbs

Representatives from the abortion fund provider Indigenous Women Rising told members of the Interim Indian Affairs Committee on Monday that their monthly abortion fund…
Study: New Mexico had highest increase in abortion since 2020

Study: New Mexico had highest increase in abortion since 2020

Between January 2020 and June 2023, New Mexico saw a larger increase in abortion than any other state, according to a new report. The…
Indigenous Women Rising: Abortion fund budget has doubled since Dobbs

Indigenous Women Rising: Abortion fund budget has doubled since Dobbs

Representatives from the abortion fund provider Indigenous Women Rising told members of the Interim Indian Affairs Committee on Monday that their monthly abortion fund…
Study: New Mexico had highest increase in abortion since 2020

Study: New Mexico had highest increase in abortion since 2020

Between January 2020 and June 2023, New Mexico saw a larger increase in abortion than any other state, according to a new report. The…
A human donor milk repository in Albuquerque needs to expand

A human donor milk repository in Albuquerque needs to expand

A human donor milk repository in Albuquerque has a growing demand and, with a need to expand, is exploring a private-public partnership to do…
Voter education campaign begins as voting begins in local elections

Voter education campaign begins as voting begins in local elections

Tuesday marked the beginning of early voting for local elections throughout the state. It also marked the beginning of a voter education public service…
Judge rules that congressional map is not an unlawful gerrymander

Judge rules that congressional map is not an unlawful gerrymander

A judge upheld the congressional maps that Republicans alleged included illegal gerrymandering, particularly in the case of the state’s 2nd Congressional District. Ninth Judicial…
State treasurer fined by State Ethics Commission for campaign finance violations

State treasurer fined by State Ethics Commission for campaign finance violations

The State Ethics Commission ruled that State Treasurer Laura Montoya, a Democrat, violated the state Campaign Reporting Act while she was a candidate in…
State supreme court upholds congressional map

State supreme court upholds congressional map

In issuing this ruling, the state Supreme Court upheld a district court decision and denied an appeal by the Republican Party of New Mexico.
Experts tell legislators about ‘black box’ AI

Experts tell legislators about ‘black box’ AI

The Interim Legislative Science, Technology and Telecommunication Committee discussed how to build transparency into artificial intelligence programming regarding public resources and services at their…
How price impacts individuals buying menstrual products

How price impacts individuals buying menstrual products

Merrill said she started Free Flow New Mexico during the early part of the pandemic because she saw a need.  “I was wondering where…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report