U.S. Supreme Court could roll back LGBTQ equality

A court case that could affect anti-discrimination laws in New Mexico will soon be before the U.S. Supreme Court. The case, Fulton v. the City of Philadelphia, will be heard by the Supreme Court next month. The case involves a Catholic-based organization that sued the city of Philadelphia because the city refused to allow the […]

U.S. Supreme Court could roll back LGBTQ equality

A court case that could affect anti-discrimination laws in New Mexico will soon be before the U.S. Supreme Court.

The case, Fulton v. the City of Philadelphia, will be heard by the Supreme Court next month. The case involves a Catholic-based organization that sued the city of Philadelphia because the city refused to allow the organization to continue a contract to house youth in foster care because the organization discriminates against same-sex couples.

Marshall Martinez, interim executive director of Equality New Mexico, said that if the case is decided by a conservative majority on the court, then a contractor who receives tax payer funding to provide, for instance, homeless shelter services or foodbank services through a government contract could refuse to house or provide food to queer or transgender people.

Martinez said that if the court rules against the city of Philadelphia broadly and bases its opinion on a religious argument, then the case could be interpreted to allow one faith-based organization to discriminate against people of other faiths and deny services to people of other faiths.

Since the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the conservative bloc on the Supreme Court gained a 5 to 3 majority on the bench. If Judge Amy Coney Barrett is nominated by the U.S. Senate, then the court will have a 6 to 3 conservative voting bloc.

“Given the history of Barrett, if she is confirmed, this ruling could be very bad for services and for folks seeking services across the country,” Martinez told NM Political Report. “But here in New Mexico, where the majority believes in equal access and equal opportunity, one organization could determine what is best to do with taxpayer money based on its own religious beliefs.”

There are other reasons, particularly for New Mexico residents who identify as LGBTQ, to be concerned about a Barrett confirmation, Martinez said.

Earlier this week Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito wrote a dissent when the court declined to hear a case brought by Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis who refused to issue marriage licenses to same sex couples in 2015.

Although both Thomas and Alito agreed with the court’s decision not to hear the Davis case, Thomas wrote in his dissent that religious liberty is being infringed upon by the court’s marriage equality ruling of 2015 and said the problem was one that “only the court can fix.”

Martinez said that Thomas’ dissent is “a clear signal to folks that this is the avenue they should fight.” Martinez said should a move could embolden state legislatures to start passing discrimination laws against same sex marriage that would then be challenged in court.

Martinez said Thomas’ dissent shows that marriage equality “is not close to over,” for the LGBTQ community.

“Two very conservative justices took the first opportunity they can to attack marriage equality under the guise of freedom of religion. I think this is a reminder to the LGBTQ community and their allies that there are still folks who are going to use every opportunity they can to take away the rights we fought for,” Martinez said.

Carrie Hamblen, who is running in an open race as a Democrat for state Senate District 38 against Republican Charles Wendler, was, along with her wife, the fifth same-sex couple in New Mexico to be married in 2013. Doña Ana County County Clerk Lynn Ellins made history in New Mexico when he decided the state constitution did not prohibit same-sex marriages and he began to issue licenses. Hamblen and her wife dropped their work, met at the courthouse and got married the same day Ellis began issuing the licenses, she said.

Shortly after, the state supreme court ruled that same-sex marriage was legal in New Mexico.

A previous attempt to issue same-sex marriage licenses in Sandoval County in 2004 resulted in those licenses being invalidated, Hamblen said. In 2013, then-Attorney General Gary King said in an opinion that the licenses should be valid unless specifically voided by a judge.

“We always felt married,” Hamblen said of herself and her wife. “The really important thing for us to have it legalized is what every gay couple goes through. If something happens to your partner in the emergency room, you don’t have access because you’re not legally connected to that person.”

Hamblen said she and her wife have not faced that problem, but she said she knows dozens of other gay couples who have.

“To have those protections snatched away from us, because of somebody’s fundamental belief rather than what is just and right under the law is a disgusting display of a lack of humanity and consideration,” Hamblen said of the potential for the Supreme Court to revisit marriage equality.

Other benefits same sex couples gain by marriage include being able to file taxes jointly, being legally able to hold mutual investments, a home and savings plan together and being covered on a spouse’s health insurance policy, Hamblen said.

Without the legal protections that marriage affords, Hamblen said that if her spouse predeceased her, she could potentially be “kicked out of my house because our relationship would not be recognized as legal. I could be denied access to our mutual investments and savings plan. I could lose health insurance benefits.”

Ellins, who is now a Doña Ana County Commissioner, told NM Political Report that the state supreme court’s ruling on same sex marriage, which came after he began issuing same sex licenses in 2013, would protect same sex marriage in the state in the event the Supreme Court should reinterpret the marriage equality ruling it proffered in 2015.

“No matter what the [U.S.] Supreme Court does, we have a state supreme court ruling that protects gay marriage, so it wouldn’t affect us here in New Mexico,” Ellins said.

But, Martinez said that the Supreme Court could “come at it from a different angle.”

He said that if the Supreme Court ruled against marriage equality from the “guise” of religious freedom, “a rural county clerk could say ‘I have a religious right to refuse these marriage licenses,’ then same sex couples in that county could have to travel hundreds of miles to get married.”

“It could be the law on paper but only on paper. It would be inaccessible to some people in some communities,” Martinez said.

Hamblen said that New Mexico has some of the strongest anti-discrimination laws in the country. But, she warned, the battle is not over.

“We have to make sure that queer couples have the same protections that heterosexual couples have and don’t have to worry about the Supreme Court deciding is null and void,” she said.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

Politics Newsletter: Special Session recap

Politics Newsletter: Special Session recap

Hello fellow political junkies! Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham called a special session on July 18 to tackle public safety issues ranging from criminal competency…
Legislators pass disaster assistance funding, end special session quickly

Legislators pass disaster assistance funding, end special session quickly

The two issues passed were only a fraction of what Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham had on her special session agenda.
House votes to pass bill for fire relief, behavioral health treatments

House votes to pass bill for fire relief, behavioral health treatments

The House voted overwhelmingly to pass HB 1, the appropriations bill that provides funding for the special session, fire relief and behavioral health court…
PRC approves NM Gas Co. rate increase agreement

PRC approves NM Gas Co. rate increase agreement

The New Mexico Public Regulation Commission approved a stipulated agreement which is expected to result in a rate increase for customers.  The stipulated agreement…
12 tribes and pueblos in New Mexico could benefit from pending water rights settlements

12 tribes and pueblos in New Mexico could benefit from pending water rights settlements

For generations, the Zuni people were able to grow food in the New Mexico desert through what Pueblo of Zuni Gov. Arden Kucate described…

Climate change is bringing more deadly heat to New Mexico

Heat-related deaths and illnesses are increasing in New Mexico, as the state has experienced greater increases in temperature than many other parts of the…
Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

About 200 people from tribal governors to legislators to advocates and teachers gathered at Bishop’s Lodge to discuss Early Childhood Education’s future in New…
Stansbury outlines funding secured for early childhood and youth services programs

Stansbury outlines funding secured for early childhood and youth services programs

U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury secured $8.3 million for childhood development and youth services in the 1st congressional district through federal community project funding. Stansbury,…
Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican The main things that bring Brayan Chavez to school every day: Seeing, talking to and engaging with…
Some mental health issues on the rise in New Mexico

Some mental health issues on the rise in New Mexico

A recent report by KFF, a foundation that provides health policy analysis, found mental health issues on the rise and disparities in mental health…
Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

U.S. Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Dr. Robert Califf answered questions about the safety of human milk formula and mifepristone on Wednesday. Sen. Martin…
Health workers fear it’s profits before protection as CDC revisits airborne transmission

Health workers fear it’s profits before protection as CDC revisits airborne transmission

Amy Maxmen, KFF Health News Four years after hospitals in New York City overflowed with covid-19 patients, emergency physician Sonya Stokes remains shaken by…
Harris could excite Democratic voters on reproductive health

Harris could excite Democratic voters on reproductive health

Data indicates Vice President Kamala Harris could excite the Democratic base around the issue of abortion in a way that President Joe Biden struggled…
Reproductive rights groups endorse Vice President Kamala Harris for president

Reproductive rights groups endorse Vice President Kamala Harris for president

Vice President Kamala Harris, who announced on Sunday her intention to replace President Joe Biden as the presidential Democratic nominee, received immediate support from…
Heinrich files amendment to protect reproductive rights for the military

Heinrich files amendment to protect reproductive rights for the military

U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich filed an amendment on Tuesday to codify a rule protecting veteran access to abortion in the case of rape, incest…
Supreme Court upends environmental and reproductive rights protections

Supreme Court upends environmental and reproductive rights protections

Two years after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the high court overturned another long-standing precedent on Friday that could undue both…
Supreme Court dismisses abortion case, advocates say it keeps legal questions open

Supreme Court dismisses abortion case, advocates say it keeps legal questions open

The Supreme Court punted on Thursday on a second abortion decision it heard this term, leaving open the question of whether a federal law…
Biden will protect reproductive access, Health Secretary says during a multi-state reproductive access tour 

Biden will protect reproductive access, Health Secretary says during a multi-state reproductive access tour 

U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra said at a Planned Parenthood space for LGBTQ youth in Albuquerque that if President Joe Biden…
Harris could excite Democratic voters on reproductive health

Harris could excite Democratic voters on reproductive health

Data indicates Vice President Kamala Harris could excite the Democratic base around the issue of abortion in a way that President Joe Biden struggled…
Reproductive rights groups endorse Vice President Kamala Harris for president

Reproductive rights groups endorse Vice President Kamala Harris for president

Vice President Kamala Harris, who announced on Sunday her intention to replace President Joe Biden as the presidential Democratic nominee, received immediate support from…
Talking to NM Democratic delegates after Biden leaves race, endorses Harris

Talking to NM Democratic delegates after Biden leaves race, endorses Harris

President Joe Biden ended his re-election campaign on Sunday leaving questions about what happens to the ballot now. Rules were already in place for…
MLG public safety town hall draws crowd

MLG public safety town hall draws crowd

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham held the first of three planned public safety town hall meetings in Las Cruces on Thursday to promote her special…
Harris could excite Democratic voters on reproductive health

Harris could excite Democratic voters on reproductive health

Data indicates Vice President Kamala Harris could excite the Democratic base around the issue of abortion in a way that President Joe Biden struggled…
Reproductive rights groups endorse Vice President Kamala Harris for president

Reproductive rights groups endorse Vice President Kamala Harris for president

Vice President Kamala Harris, who announced on Sunday her intention to replace President Joe Biden as the presidential Democratic nominee, received immediate support from…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report