Rules frozen by Trump could melt away without a trace

Ridding day care centers of fluorescent lightbulbs with toxic PCBs. Requiring a backup engineer on freight trains to avoid crashes. Restricting drones from flying over people. Federal agencies were preparing these rules and dozens more when Donald Trump was elected. In one of his first acts, the president quietly froze them. That isn’t unusual. Presidents […]

Rules frozen by Trump could melt away without a trace

Ridding day care centers of fluorescent lightbulbs with toxic PCBs. Requiring a backup engineer on freight trains to avoid crashes. Restricting drones from flying over people.

Federal agencies were preparing these rules and dozens more when Donald Trump was elected. In one of his first acts, the president quietly froze them. That isn’t unusual. Presidents Clinton, Bush and Obama signed similar orders.

Unlike in previous administrations, however, this time the proposed rules are long shots to be finished and enacted. Because of “the very clear signals of an anti-regulatory mandate from the president,” they are less likely to be implemented than in prior eras, according to Sally Katzen, a New York University law professor and former deputy director for management at the Office of Management and Budget. Instead, they may vanish with little or no announcement or explanation. Already, they have disappeared from the main federal website that lists rules in the works.

Related: Dems in delegation give thumbs down to new Trump travel ban

Five federal agencies contacted by ProPublica said they are reviewing regulations but declined to address specifically the pending rules that were put on hold. A spokesman for the Health Resources and Services Administration said his agency is pursuing “efforts to reduce regulatory burden.” The White House did not respond to a request for comment.

While the media and the public focus on the Russia scandal or who has the ear of the president, the Trump administration and the Republican-controlled Congress are conducting a broad assault on regulations. Trump, making regulatory rollback a centerpiece of his administration, contends onerous rules stifle American businesses and the economy. Steve Bannon, his chief strategist, promised supporters a “deconstruction of the administrative state.” On Monday, The New York Times surveyed the sweeping efforts to roll back environmental rules, restrictions on Wall Street, and other limitations on businesses of every stripe.

Finalized rules cannot be easily rescinded. Doing so often requires some congressional action. And agencies typically must explain why they are canceling a rule. Groups that object sometimes sue to preserve the regulations.

But dozens of rules are pending and those may be easier to kill. After previous administrations’ freezes, agencies examined proposed rules and went forward with the vast majority, according to administrative law experts. This time may be different. A few days after his freeze, Trump signed another executive order on Jan. 30, ordering that agencies cut two old regulations for each new one. Given that edict, federal agencies, like the Department of Transportation or the Environmental Protection Agency, may resist finalizing pending rules.

Regulations often undergo review for years before they take effect. Typically, after a law is passed, the appropriate agency comes up with proposed rules for implementing it, and puts them out for public comment. Supporters and opponents (often corporations or their representatives) weigh in. The agency then edits the rules and sends them to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, a body within the Office of Management and Budget. There, the office conducts an economic analysis to make sure the costs don’t outweigh the benefits. Finally, if the new regulations clear all the hurdles, they are published in the Federal Register. After 60 or 90 days, they become effective.

At least 25 rules were waiting on the OIRA runway for final approval in the waning days of the Obama administration. Some had gone through the entire process and merely required being sent to the Federal Register. (A separate group of regulations were at the Federal Register but had not become effective. These are on hold as well.)

Among the pending rules was a Department of Transportation initiative calling for all railroad operations to have at least two crew members. Proponents say the rule could minimize the risk of a repeat of the 2013 Canadian train accident in which a derailed, unattended locomotive became a burning missile hurtling through a small Canadian town called Lac-Mégantic, killing 47 people and spilling 6 million liters of crude oil. The railroad industry has objected to the new restriction, contending the rule is too costly and unlikely to minimize accidents.

Another rule would require that fluorescent lights in daycares and schools contain no PCBs, which can become toxic when burned. Still others cover everything from grain elevator performance to disclosures about foods that have been bioengineered.

Trump’s two-for-one edict already faces problems. It stipulates that the incremental cost of new regulations in 2017 must be zero: In other words, that discarding two regulations must save as much money as the new regulation costs. The trouble with this approach is that regulations typically entail large upfront investments, but little in the way of ongoing outlays. For instance, if the government requires retrofitting of certain plants with safer machines, that’s expensive at first. But once manufacturers have complied, the ongoing cost is minimal. Therefore, to find enough savings to offset a new regulation might mean cutting many more than two old ones.

Perhaps more significantly, scholars argue that the Trump order is against the law. “Agencies do not simply regulate for the sake of regulation 2014 each regulation is aimed at implementing a specific provision of a statute passed by Congress,” Columbia Law School’s Michael Burger and Jessica Wentz wrote recently. Indeed, liberal groups Public Citizen, the National Resources Defense and the Communications Workers of American filed a lawsuit to block the Trump executive order, contending it is arbitrary.

But there’s little legal recourse for resurrecting proposed rules, which might be shelved without any public notice. If agencies do so, it’s unclear if they have to explain why. Liberal interest groups argue that ditching pending rules without a legitimate justification might not stand up to a court challenge, though they concede it’s uncharted territory. They say rules that have undergone public comments and other scrutiny may also be protected under the prohibitions against arbitrary regulatory decisions.

“We believe it is illegal to kill a final rule without good reason, not just that Donald Trump doesn’t like rules,” said Rena Steinzor, a law professor at the University of Maryland and former president of Center for Progressive Reform, a think tank. “That’s not good enough.”

ProPublica is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative newsroom. Sign up for their newsletter.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

Perhaps the most vilified population in the United States during the first Trump Administration were immigrants. This vilification is only rising. Trump plans to…
State Rep. Alcon steps down, cites health concerns

State Rep. Alcon steps down, cites health concerns

State Rep. Eliseo “Lee” Alcon, D-Milan, announced his retirement from the legislature Saturday citing health issues as the reason. The retirement was effective immediately.…
Politics Newsletter: potential immigration legislation

Politics Newsletter: potential immigration legislation

Hello fellow political junkies! New Mexico immigrant advocacy groups announced their legislative proposals during a press conference Nov. 22. The proposals include not allowing…
PNM plans to build a new solar facility in northwest New Mexico

PNM plans to build a new solar facility in northwest New Mexico

A new solar and battery storage facility known as the Sunbelt Project could be coming to the Central Consolidated School District in northwest New…
NM launches phase two of rebate program on Black Friday

NM launches phase two of rebate program on Black Friday

People looking to upgrade to new energy-efficient appliances may be in luck this Black Friday. The New Mexico Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department…
NMED releases final strategic water supply feasibility study

NMED releases final strategic water supply feasibility study

More details are now available about a controversial plan to use treated produced and brackish water for industrial purposes. Produced water is a byproduct…
Head Start could be threatened under Trump

Head Start could be threatened under Trump

A popular program that enjoys bipartisan support, Head Start, could be under threat under a second Donald Trump administration. Project 2025 calls for the…
MLG speaks about education during oil, gas industry meeting

MLG speaks about education during oil, gas industry meeting

New Mexico produces the second highest amount of oil and gas in the country. The taxes from oil and gas production provide funding for…
Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

Early childhood summit convened to discuss future of program

About 200 people from tribal governors to legislators to advocates and teachers gathered at Bishop’s Lodge to discuss Early Childhood Education’s future in New…
Heinrich introduces legislation to address affordable housing

Heinrich introduces legislation to address affordable housing

U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich, D-New Mexico, introduced legislation in the Senate on Monday that would provide tax credits to incentivize new investments and additional…
New Mexico in critical nursing shortage

New Mexico in critical nursing shortage

With 8,800 nurse positions posted for hiring in New Mexico, hospital leadership told the Legislative Health and Human Services Committee on Tuesday that access…
As rhetoric around undocumented workers heats up, new report shows their tax contribution

As rhetoric around undocumented workers heats up, new report shows their tax contribution

A nonprofit group released data showing how much taxes migrants pay in the U.S. as rhetoric on immigration grows more prominent just months from…
Abortion care: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

Abortion care: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

With a Republican trifecta going forward, the right to an abortion and the ability to obtain one will be at high risk even in…
Indigenous Women Rising rebrands amid decrease in donations and increased costs

Indigenous Women Rising rebrands amid decrease in donations and increased costs

Indigenous Women Rising, a grassroots abortion fund provider supporting Native individuals, is experiencing a decrease in donations while, simultaneously, an increase in those needing…
U.S. Supreme Court has one bodily autonomy case on its docket

U.S. Supreme Court has one bodily autonomy case on its docket

With the U.S. Supreme Court refusing to hear one reproductive rights case this term, the high court has only one case on its docket…
Stansbury announces bill to expand medical residencies in Tribal communities

Stansbury announces bill to expand medical residencies in Tribal communities

U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury introduced a bill that would provide $4 million annually to create an office within the Indian Health Service to oversee…
Sexual assault helpline launches during Domestic Violence Awareness Month

Sexual assault helpline launches during Domestic Violence Awareness Month

A new, dedicated statewide sexual assault helpline officially went live on Monday. The New Mexico Coalition of Sexual Assault Programs launched the helpline to…
Golden Opportunity to use community collaboration to battle opioid epidemic

Golden Opportunity to use community collaboration to battle opioid epidemic

The opioid epidemic is easing in the Albuquerque area and more help is on the way, according to the New Mexico Department of Health.…
New Mexico completes election canvass, two recounts triggered

New Mexico completes election canvass, two recounts triggered

The State Canvass Board certified the New Mexico 2024 general election results Tuesday in Santa Fe. The board, comprised of Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham,…
LGBTQ rights: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

LGBTQ rights: What’s at risk under a second Trump term

Within the first two days after the general election earlier this month, LGBTQ crisis lines in the U.S. experienced a 700 percent increase in…
Politics Newsletter: Election recap

Politics Newsletter: Election recap

Hello fellow political junkies! The election is over (finally) but the work of government continues as does the work of covering and chronicling the…
Artificial Intelligence regulation under Trump

Artificial Intelligence regulation under Trump

As artificial intelligence becomes more commonplace, Congress is attempting to put in place some regulations designed to mitigate against potential risks. Proponents of the…
Trump likely to change regs protecting against sex-based discrimination in schools

Trump likely to change regs protecting against sex-based discrimination in schools

President-elect Donald Trump is likely to return the regulation, Title IX, that protects against sex-based discrimination, to previous rules which could harm LGBTQ individuals…
‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

‘Not only draconian… immoral’: NM legislators, advocates talk Trump deportation plans

Perhaps the most vilified population in the United States during the first Trump Administration were immigrants. This vilification is only rising. Trump plans to…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report