Professor questions merits of lawsuit seeking to weaken abortion rights law

The City of Eunice is suing state officials in an effort to maintain its anti-abortion ordinance despite a recent state law enacted to end such maneuvers, but the legal argument may not hold water.   But the city’s argument relies on a 150-year-old law that the U.S. Supreme Court made null and void in 1965, University […]

Professor questions merits of lawsuit seeking to weaken abortion rights law

The City of Eunice is suing state officials in an effort to maintain its anti-abortion ordinance despite a recent state law enacted to end such maneuvers, but the legal argument may not hold water.  

But the city’s argument relies on a 150-year-old law that the U.S. Supreme Court made null and void in 1965, University of New Mexico Law Professor Joshua Kastenberg told NM Political Report.

This law is known as the Comstock Act, which prohibited “abortifacients,” drugs used to induce abortions, from being sent through the U.S. Postal Service.

The city of Eunice’s legal filing earlier this week states that when the U.S. Supreme Court decided Roe v. Wade in 1973, it made the Comstock Act of 1873 no longer enforceable. The city’s filing also states that since the court overturned Roe last year, the Comstock Act is now enforceable again. 

Kastenberg said that, while he wouldn’t call this a frivolous lawsuit, he also wouldn’t call it a winning one.

He said that the Supreme Court’s 1965 ruling on Griswold  v. Connecticut, not Roe v. Wade, is what made the Comstock Act null and void. In the previous decades, courts chipped away at the Comstock Act. In addition, the court has not overturned its Griswold v. Connecticut decision, which ended state bans on contraception between married couples. This means that the Comstock Act is still null and void, Kastenberg said.

Kastenberg said the legal gray area lies in the fact that the court did not explicitly overturn the Comstock Act when it decided Griswold v. Connecticut. The court relied on the Fourth Amendment, which protects people from unreasonable search and seizure, for its reasoning.  But, Kastenberg said, there are several important differences at play between 1873 when Congress enacted the Comstock Act and now.

One is that in the 1800s, the abortion medication women received through the mail were sometimes “junk,” Kastenberg said. 

The 1906 Pure Food and Drugs Act created the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, which has the authority to regulate abortion medicines. This law came as a response to abuses in the meatpacking industry.

Kastenberg said the “abortifacients” as they were called at the time, came with considerable risk because the federal government did not regulate medicine prior to the Theodore Roosevelt administration in the early 20th Century.

“It was not until Teddy Roosevelt who said, ‘we need an agency.’ Before that, a guy comes into town on a wagon with bottled up sources of alcohol and says it solves everything from arthritis to heart problems,” Kastenberg said.

Kastenberg said the ways in which people think about laws have also evolved.

For instance, a court indicted birth control activist Margaret Sanger in the early 1900s because she mailed pamphlets informing women about birth control. Kastenberg said that our understanding of the First Amendment right to free speech has expanded since that era and now a person in Sanger’s situation would never be indicted for mailing pamphlets with birth control information because of First Amendment rights.

“What they’re doing with the Comstock Act is reminiscent of an individual going back to ancient law to see if it’s still good. Usually that doesn’t work…It’s rendered void through other things. The Comstock law is one of them,” he said.

What is the Comstock Act?

The history of the Comstock Act begins with its namesake, Anthony Comstock.

“In those days, the U.S. Postal Inspector had to be approved by the U.S. Senate. He was a special agent for the post office, a Victorian-minded, upright man of the time,” Kastenberg said.

Kastenberg said Comstock lobbied Congress to regulate the U.S. mail because of what he saw going through it at the time. Congress complied and passed the act, named for Comstock, in 1873.  

But times were very different then, Kastenberg said. He likened it to a state that has never taken an environmental regulation off the statute that allowed arsenic to pass into drinking water.

“Imagine relying on that law 100 years later,” he said.

Kastenberg said that, in addition, what passed as “obscene” in 1873 is not the same as now. He said that some regarded Elvis Presley as “obscene” in the 1950s.

“But very few things in our life today are considered to be obscene,” he said and what consenting adults do in private is “off limits to the law.”

Kastenberg said the change in attitude toward obscenity laws really began after World War II.

He said that, in addition to the morality of Victorian times, the era of Prohibition in the 1930s gave the federal government considerable authority to interfere in the lives of individuals. 

But by 1954, that changed, at least in part, due to the Supreme Court becoming the Earl Warren court. Warren was the chief justice of the court from 1954 to 1969. He is credited with expanding civil liberties and the beginning of racial equality through the court’s Brown v. Board of Education decision.

Warren was a Dwight Eisenhower appointee and was considered to be a moderate Republican.

Kastenberg also said the Supreme Court case Lawrence v. Texas, decided in 2003, shows how far we have come from the moral standards of Victorian times. Lawrence v. Texas ended state bans on same-sex couples.

“The world of the Comstock Act of 1873 is the world of President Ulysses S. Grant. What constituted public morals and the states’ ability to intrude in those public morals is fundamentally different from today,” Kastenberg said.

We're ad free

That means that we rely on support from readers like you. Help us keep reporting on the most important New Mexico Stories by donating today.

Related

Senators throw support to embattled Ivey-Soto

Senators throw support to embattled Ivey-Soto

By Justin Horwath, New Mexico In Dept Sen. Daniel Ivey-Soto is running for a fourth term despite the state Democratic Party’s decision to censure…
AG announces legislative priorities for upcoming special session

AG announces legislative priorities for upcoming special session

Attorney General Raúl Torrez announced on Thursday his legislative priorities for July’s special legislative session, including the creation of a crime victim’s unit to…
Correa Hemphill to step down from legislature

Correa Hemphill to step down from legislature

State Sen. Siah Correa Hemphill, a Democrat from Silver City, won’t seek reelection in the general election in November, leaving SD 28, a swing…
EPA announces $18.9M in funding to address PFAS contamination in New Mexico

EPA announces $18.9M in funding to address PFAS contamination in New Mexico

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency awarded the New Mexico Environment Department nearly $19 million to address PFAS and other emerging contaminants in drinking water.…
Environmental historian reflects on the legacies of Aldo Leopold and the Gila Wilderness

Environmental historian reflects on the legacies of Aldo Leopold and the Gila Wilderness

One hundred years ago, conservationist Aldo Leopold proposed designating 500,000 acres of land in the Gila National Forest as an area where no roads…

A rare NM lizard is now listed as endangered

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service added the dunes sagebrush lizard to the list of endangered species on Friday and is expected to designate…
Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

Amid new graduation requirements, what do high schoolers want to learn?

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican The main things that bring Brayan Chavez to school every day: Seeing, talking to and engaging with…
Special ed teachers hope lawmakers OK pay raises, admin changes

Special ed teachers hope lawmakers OK pay raises, admin changes

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican Brittany Behenna Griffith has a laundry list of adjectives to describe the ideal special education teacher:…
Lawmakers must find consensus on competing education spending plans

Lawmakers must find consensus on competing education spending plans

By Margaret O’Hara, The Santa Fe New Mexican A challenging task awaits New Mexico lawmakers in the next 30 days: Reconciling three very different…
Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

U.S. Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Dr. Robert Califf answered questions about the safety of human milk formula and mifepristone on Wednesday. Sen. Martin…
Health workers fear it’s profits before protection as CDC revisits airborne transmission

Health workers fear it’s profits before protection as CDC revisits airborne transmission

Amy Maxmen, KFF Health News Four years after hospitals in New York City overflowed with covid-19 patients, emergency physician Sonya Stokes remains shaken by…
Lujan Grisham, Biden admin announce $10 million in federal funds for tribes, pueblos

Lujan Grisham, Biden admin announce $10 million in federal funds for tribes, pueblos

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced Friday $10 million in funding from the federal American Rescue Plan Act was awarded to six tribal nations and…
Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham warned that banning contraceptives “could be next” when talking to a CNN host about New Mexico’s border and abortion issues.…
UNM approves land acquisition for Las Cruces reproductive health center

UNM approves land acquisition for Las Cruces reproductive health center

Thursday, the University of New Mexico Board of Regents approved a land acquisition for a full-spectrum reproductive healthcare center, that will include abortion care,…
Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

Heinrich questions FDA leadership on baby formula safety, mifepristone

U.S. Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Dr. Robert Califf answered questions about the safety of human milk formula and mifepristone on Wednesday. Sen. Martin…
Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham warned that banning contraceptives “could be next” when talking to a CNN host about New Mexico’s border and abortion issues.…
Study: Marriage equality has had a positive impact

Study: Marriage equality has had a positive impact

A recent study found that in the 20 years since Massachusetts became the first state in the U.S. to grant same-sex marriage licenses, same-sex…
UNM approves land acquisition for Las Cruces reproductive health center

UNM approves land acquisition for Las Cruces reproductive health center

Thursday, the University of New Mexico Board of Regents approved a land acquisition for a full-spectrum reproductive healthcare center, that will include abortion care,…
Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham warned that banning contraceptives “could be next” when talking to a CNN host about New Mexico’s border and abortion issues.…
Senators throw support to embattled Ivey-Soto

Senators throw support to embattled Ivey-Soto

By Justin Horwath, New Mexico In Dept Sen. Daniel Ivey-Soto is running for a fourth term despite the state Democratic Party’s decision to censure…
Correa Hemphill to step down from legislature

Correa Hemphill to step down from legislature

State Sen. Siah Correa Hemphill, a Democrat from Silver City, won’t seek reelection in the general election in November, leaving SD 28, a swing…
EPA announces $18.9M in funding to address PFAS contamination in New Mexico

EPA announces $18.9M in funding to address PFAS contamination in New Mexico

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency awarded the New Mexico Environment Department nearly $19 million to address PFAS and other emerging contaminants in drinking water.…
State putting pressure on firms that manage Medicaid to help solve behavioral health access problems

State putting pressure on firms that manage Medicaid to help solve behavioral health access problems

By Gabrielle Porter, The Santa Fe New Mexican New Mexico’s Medicaid middlemen need more skin in the game. That’s the message from Human Services…
Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Lujan Grisham talks reproductive healthcare with CNN host

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham warned that banning contraceptives “could be next” when talking to a CNN host about New Mexico’s border and abortion issues.…

GET INVOLVED

© 2023 New Mexico Political Report